Consideration Blog Post 63  ✦ High Value

Revenue Analysis in a QoE Report: Is the Revenue Real, Repeatable, and Growing?

Total revenue tells you almost nothing. What matters is who pays, for what, how often, and whether it will still be there after the sale.

Nick Ringling
Nick Ringling
Founder, ClearView QoE  ·  About Nick
Published:

A listing says a business makes $1.8 million a year. That is one number, and it can hide almost everything a buyer needs to know. Who pays? For what? How often? Is it growing because of more customers, or because of one big job? Revenue analysis is the part of a quality of earnings (QoE) review that answers those questions.

Quick answer: Revenue analysis breaks a business's sales into pieces: by customer, by product or service line, and by month or year. It separates recurring revenue from one time revenue, shows how dependent the business is on a few customers, and tests whether growth comes from price, volume, or a single event. It also ties the revenue to bank deposits so you know it is real.

Why total revenue is not enough

Two businesses can both report $1.8 million and be worth very different amounts. One has 400 customers who buy every month. The other had one large project that will not repeat. A buyer pays for future earnings, and future earnings depend on which kind of revenue they are. Our guide to revenue quality explains the general idea. This post is about how the analysis is done.

Four cuts of the data

CutQuestion it answers
By customerHow concentrated is the revenue, and who are the top ten?
By product or service lineWhich lines make money, which are shrinking, and which depend on a few buyers?
By periodIs revenue growing, flat, or falling, and what does the seasonal pattern look like?
By typeHow much is recurring, repeat, or one time?

1. By customer

Start with the top ten customers and the share each one represents. A business where one customer is 30 percent of sales is exposed if that customer leaves. Look at how long the top customers have been there, whether they have contracts, and whether the relationship is with the owner personally. We cover this in detail in our guide to customer concentration risk.

2. By product or service line

Most businesses sell more than one thing. Splitting revenue by line shows which parts are growing and which are fading. A business can look stable overall while its best line shrinks and a lower margin line fills the gap. Pair the revenue split with margin by line, as in our gross margin analysis guide.

3. By period

Look at revenue by month for at least two to three years. This shows the real trend and the seasonal pattern, and it shows whether the latest months are being pushed up before a sale. Compare the trailing twelve months with the prior year, as described in seasonality and trailing twelve months.

4. By type: recurring or not

Sort revenue into three groups. Recurring revenue comes from contracts or subscriptions. Repeat revenue comes from customers who buy again but are not committed. One time revenue comes from a project or a sale that may not happen again. Buyers should value these differently. Here is a simplified example, with made-up numbers for illustration.

TypeRevenueShare
Recurring (contracts)$720,00040%
Repeat (customers who return)$810,00045%
One time project$270,00015%
Total$1,800,000100%

If the one time project is removed, repeatable revenue is $1,530,000, not $1,800,000. A buyer who prices off the larger figure is paying for sales that may not come back.

Growth: price, volume, or one big event

Revenue growth is only as good as its source. Break it into price (higher prices on the same work), volume (more customers or more units), and one off events. Price-driven growth can be real, but it may not continue. Volume growth from many customers is usually stronger than growth from one large account. In the example below, revenue rose by $200,000.

Source of growthAmount
Price increases on existing customers$60,000
New customers (volume)$40,000
One large project that will not repeat$100,000
Total growth$200,000

Half of that growth came from a single project. The underlying growth is closer to $100,000.

Is the revenue real?

Revenue also has to be tested against cash. Compare sales to bank deposits month by month, the way a proof of cash does. Differences can come from timing, refunds, customer credits, or sales recorded before they were earned. Check the last few months before a sale especially, since revenue pulled forward makes the trailing numbers look better than they are.

What a QoE checks

A QoE will not forecast how customers will behave under a new owner. What it does is show you what the revenue really is today, so your forecast starts from facts.

Common questions

How many customers should I look at?

At least the top ten, and ideally the full customer list for the past two to three years. The top ten show concentration, and the full list shows how many customers stay, leave, or are new.

Is one time revenue always bad?

No. Some businesses sell projects as a normal part of the model. The issue is whether new projects come in at a steady rate. If they do, the revenue is repeatable even if each job is unique.

What is a good level of recurring revenue?

It depends on the industry. Subscription and contract businesses can have most revenue recurring. Project businesses will have less. Compare the number to similar businesses and to how the price is set.

Can revenue be overstated?

Yes. Common causes are sales recorded early, unrecorded refunds and credits, and one time deals presented as normal. Matching sales to deposits and reviewing the months around the sale helps catch them.

Bottom line: Revenue is only worth what you can expect to keep. Break it down by customer, product, period, and type, and test it against the bank, before you pay a multiple.

Want the revenue behind the listing verified?

ClearView QoE breaks revenue down by customer, product line, and period to identify concentration risk, growth trends, and revenue quality. CPA-reviewed, fixed fee, 10 business days or less.

Talk to Nick