Consideration Blog Post 59  ✦ High Value

Gross Margin Analysis in a QoE Report: What Margin Trends Tell You About the Business

Revenue says how much the business sells. Gross margin says how much of each dollar is left after the direct cost of delivering it. That is where growth is tested.

Nick Ringling
Nick Ringling
Founder, ClearView QoE  ·  About Nick
Published:

Revenue tells you how much a business sells. Gross margin tells you how much of each sales dollar is left after the direct cost of delivering the product or service. It is the line where a business shows whether it is getting more profitable as it grows, or just getting busier.

Quick answer: Gross margin is revenue minus the direct costs of delivering it, divided by revenue. In a quality of earnings (QoE) review it is checked over time, by product, service line, or customer group, and for how costs are classified. A falling margin can mean rising costs, lower prices, or a weaker sales mix. A rising margin can be real, or it can be a cost that was moved below the line. Either way, understand it before you pay a multiple on earnings.

What gross margin is, and what it is not

Gross profit is revenue minus cost of revenue (often called cost of goods sold, or COGS). Gross margin is gross profit divided by revenue. What counts as a direct cost depends on the business. In a product business it is usually the cost of the product, freight in, and packaging. In a service business it is usually direct labor, materials, subcontractors, and the vehicles and equipment used on jobs.

Gross margin is not net profit. Rent, administration, marketing, and the owner's pay all come after it. That is why it is such a useful test: it shows how well the core activity of the business works before overhead is layered on top.

Why it matters more than most buyers expect

What it looks like in practice

Here is a simplified example for a business over three years. The numbers are made up for illustration.

YearRevenueCost of revenueGross profitGross margin
Year 1$1,000,000$550,000$450,00045%
Year 2$1,100,000$627,000$473,00043%
Year 3$1,200,000$720,000$480,00040%

Revenue grew 20 percent from Year 1 to Year 3. Gross profit grew less than 7 percent, from $450,000 to $480,000. A seller who says "we have grown 20 percent" is telling the truth, but the business is keeping very little of the extra sales. The next question is why. It could be higher material prices, rising labor rates, discounting to win work, or more sales of a lower margin product. Each answer leads to a different decision about the price you should pay.

How costs get classified

Small businesses do not all draw the line between cost of revenue and operating expenses in the same place. That matters, because moving a cost across the line changes gross margin without changing earnings at all.

CostWhere it may be recordedWhy it matters
Direct labor (crews, technicians, cooks)Cost of revenue in some books, operating expenses in othersThe largest swing factor in many service businesses.
Supervisor and manager payEitherDepends on whether the role is tied to producing the work or to running the company.
SubcontractorsUsually cost of revenueCheck that it is recorded the same way every year.
Shipping and freightEitherOutbound shipping is sometimes treated as a selling expense.
Payment processing feesEitherCan be several percent of sales.
Vehicles and equipment on jobsEitherOften buried in general expenses.
Inventory write offsCost of revenue or other expenseThe timing of a write off can distort a single year.

Here is why it matters. If $90,000 of crew pay moves from cost of revenue to operating expenses, the Year 3 gross margin in the example above goes from 40 percent to 47.5 percent. Earnings are exactly the same. A gross margin figure cannot be compared to another business, or to a listing's claims, unless the costs are classified the same way.

What to look at

How it connects to add-backs and EBITDA

Gross margin problems often hide inside add-backs. A seller may label an expense as unnecessary, when it is really a direct cost of serving customers that the next owner will also have to pay. If it is a cost of doing the work, it is not optional. We cover how these claims get stretched in adjusted EBITDA and how it can be inflated and recasting financials. In an online store, the same idea is usually called contribution margin, which we describe in buying an e-commerce business.

What a QoE checks

A QoE will not tell you whether a business can raise its prices or find cheaper suppliers. What it does is show you where the margin really is and where it is going, so the earnings you are paying for are not based on a number that moved for accounting reasons.

Common questions

What is a good gross margin?

It depends on the industry and on how costs are classified, so there is no single right number. Compare a business with its own history first, then with similar businesses that classify costs the same way.

Why would a seller's gross margin change from year to year?

Real reasons include price changes, supplier costs, labor rates, and sales mix. Accounting reasons include costs moved between categories, inventory adjustments, and timing. A QoE helps tell which is which.

Is gross margin the same as profit margin?

No. Gross margin is calculated before overhead. Net profit margin is calculated after all expenses, including rent, administration, and owner pay.

Can I use gross margin to value a business?

Not directly. Small businesses are usually priced on earnings, either seller's discretionary earnings or adjusted EBITDA, as explained in our guide to SDE vs. EBITDA. Gross margin helps you judge whether those earnings are sustainable and where they may be heading.

Bottom line: Growth only helps if the business keeps a healthy share of each new dollar. Check the margin by year and by line, and make sure the costs have been classified the same way throughout, before you pay a multiple on the earnings.

Is the seller's growth actually profitable?

ClearView QoE includes gross margin analysis by product or service line, so you can see margin compression or expansion before you pay a multiple. CPA-reviewed, fixed fee, 10 business days or less.

Talk to Nick