Consideration Blog Post 57  ✦ High Value

Seasonal Businesses and Trailing Twelve Month Earnings: Why One Number Is Never Enough

Ask a seller what the business earns and the answer depends on which twelve months they pick. In a seasonal business, that choice can hide a decline.

Nick Ringling
Nick Ringling
Founder, ClearView QoE  ·  About Nick
Published:

Ask a seller what the business earns and the answer depends on which twelve months they pick. For a business with a busy season and a slow season, that choice can swing the number by tens of thousands of dollars. It can also hide a decline that is already under way.

Quick answer: A trailing twelve month (TTM) figure adds up the most recent twelve months of results, ending at whatever month the books run through. For a seasonal business it is only useful alongside the same months in earlier years. Compare each month and quarter to the same period last year, look at 24 to 36 months of history, and plan for cash in the slow season. The goal is to know whether earnings are growing, flat, or shrinking, not just what one window says.

What trailing twelve months means

A calendar year ends in December. A trailing twelve month figure ends whenever the latest books close. TTM through September covers October of last year to September of this year, and next month the window moves forward by one.

Buyers like TTM because it is the most recent full cycle, and because it always contains exactly one of each month. That means the busy season is neither double counted nor missed in the total. What it does not tell you is whether this year's busy season was better or worse than the last one.

Why one number is never enough

WindowWhat it showsWhat to watch for
Last full yearMatches the year end books and the tax return.Can be many months old by the time you are looking at the deal.
Trailing twelve monthsThe most recent full cycle.Interim books are often less polished than year end books. Check them against bank statements.
Year to date vs. same period last yearWhether this year is running ahead or behind.Early in the year it is a small sample, and one large job can swing it.
Three year trendThe direction: growing, flat, or shrinking.Only works if the accounting is consistent from year to year.
Best yearWhat a seller likes to quote.It is a peak, not a trend.

What it looks like in practice

Here is a made up seasonal business, with earnings shown by year and then as a trailing twelve month figure.

PeriodEarnings
Year 1$250,000
Year 2$240,000
Year 3$218,000
TTM through the second quarter of Year 4$201,000

That TTM figure is the last two quarters of Year 3 ($92,000 and $34,000) plus the first two quarters of Year 4 ($15,000 and $60,000). A seller who says "we do about $250,000" is quoting Year 1. Earnings have been sliding every year, and the latest quarters confirm it. The first quarter came in at $15,000 against $22,000 a year earlier, down about 32 percent. The second quarter came in at $60,000 against $70,000, down about 14 percent.

At a 3x multiple, the gap between $250,000 and $201,000 is $147,000 of purchase price. Looking at the same months year over year is what exposes it.

What to check in a seasonal business

Seasonality, cash, and your loan

Revenue comes in waves, but your loan payment is the same every month. A lender may look at coverage over a full year, while you will live through it month by month. Plan for how you will fund the slow season, whether from cash on hand or a line of credit, and ask your lender how it treats seasonal businesses.

Working capital swings with the calendar too. Many deals set the working capital target using an average over several months rather than a single month end, which keeps the closing date from favoring one side. Our guide to working capital in small business acquisitions explains how that works.

Where it matters most

Seasonality shows up in more businesses than people expect. Lawn care and landscaping peak in the growing season (see buying a landscaping business). HVAC demand follows the weather (see buying an HVAC business). Online stores often earn a big share of the year in the fourth quarter (see buying an e-commerce business). Pool service, tax preparation, and many construction trades follow a clear annual pattern as well.

What a QoE does with seasonality

A QoE will not predict next season's weather or demand. What it does is give you an honest picture of the pattern so you are negotiating on the trend, not on the seller's best twelve months.

Common questions

Is trailing twelve months better than the last calendar year?

It is usually more current, but not automatically more accurate. Interim books are often less carefully reviewed than year end books. Use both, and check the interim numbers against bank statements.

How many months of data do I need?

Monthly results for the same two to three years as the financial statements being analyzed, plus the current year to date. Fewer than 24 months makes it hard to tell a seasonal pattern from a one time event.

What if the seller only has annual numbers?

Ask for monthly profit and loss statements or a copy of the accounting file. Bank statements can also be used to rebuild monthly revenue, as we describe in our guide to the proof of cash. A seller who cannot produce any monthly data is giving you information too.

Does seasonality make a business worth less?

Not by itself. A predictable seasonal pattern is normal in many good businesses. The risks are a pattern you do not understand, a decline hidden by timing, and not having the cash to get through the slow months.

Bottom line: One twelve month window is a snapshot. Look at the same months across several years, follow the trend, and make sure you can carry the business through the slow season before you commit.

Want to see the real trend behind the seller's number?

ClearView QoE reports include month over month trend analysis, so you can see seasonality, growth, or decline before you pay a multiple. CPA-reviewed, fixed fee, 10 business days or less.

Talk to Nick