Consideration Blog Post 58  ✦ High Value

Buying a Restaurant: What to Verify in Sales, Labor, and the Lease

Restaurants are easy to find and hard to read. Thin margins, lots of cash, and a lease that matters as much as the P&L make due diligence different here.

Nick Ringling
Nick Ringling
Founder, ClearView QoE  ·  About Nick
Published:

Restaurants are among the most listed small businesses on the market, and among the hardest to read. Margins are thin, a lot of money moves through the register in cash, staff turn over, and the lease can matter as much as the profit and loss statement. A small mistake in the numbers can turn a decent looking deal into a bad one.

Quick answer: Five things decide most restaurant deals. First, whether sales tie from the point of sale (POS) system to the bank to the tax return. Second, prime cost, which is food and beverage cost plus all labor, including any unpaid labor from the owner or family. Third, the lease and whether the landlord will assign it. Fourth, licenses and permits that may not transfer automatically. Fifth, the condition of the equipment. A quality of earnings (QoE) review tests the first two directly and flags the rest.

Why restaurants are different

Most service businesses sell hours. A restaurant sells perishable product, made by a large hourly workforce, in a space it rents. Sales are made all day in small amounts, often in cash, and the profit that is left after rent, food, and labor is usually small. That leaves little room for error and makes every adjustment matter.

What to look at

AreaWhat to verify
SalesDaily POS reports tied to card processor deposits, cash deposits, delivery app payouts, and the tax return.
Prime costFood and beverage cost plus all labor (wages, payroll taxes, benefits) as a share of sales, over time.
LaborPayroll records against who actually works there. Look for unpaid family, the owner's hours, and anyone paid off the books.
Cash salesCash recorded in the POS against cash actually deposited.
Delivery appsGross sales against what the platform paid out after commissions, fees, and refunds.
Gift cards and depositsUnredeemed gift cards and catering or event deposits, which are obligations you may inherit.
EquipmentAge, condition, liens, and what is leased rather than owned.
LeaseRemaining term, renewal options, rent as a share of sales, assignment rights, and any personal guaranty.
Licenses and permitsHealth permits, any liquor license, and whether each one transfers or has to be applied for again.
Sales and payroll taxWhether returns were filed and taxes paid on time.

1. Sales: POS to bank to tax return

A POS system gives you a level of detail that most small businesses do not have: sales by day, by item, by hour. Use it, but do not stop there. Tie the POS totals to what was deposited by the card processor and to the cash deposits at the bank. This is the same idea as a proof of cash, and in a business that handles this much cash it is the most important test we would run. We explain how it works in our guide to the proof of cash.

Then compare the totals to the tax return. A seller who reports one number to buyers and a lower one to the government has handed you a problem. Our guide to tax return reconciliation covers what to look for.

Cash needs special attention. Cash sales are normal. Cash that was never recorded or never deposited is the issue. If a seller says some sales were cash that never hit the books, treat that income as unverified until someone proves otherwise. A lender cannot count money it cannot see, and neither can you.

2. Prime cost

Prime cost is food and beverage cost plus all labor, expressed as a percentage of sales. It is the number operators watch most closely. A commonly cited rule of thumb is to keep it around 60 to 65 percent of sales, though the right target varies by type of restaurant.

The trap is what counts as labor. If the owner works every shift without pay, or family members work for free, the P&L understates labor and flatters earnings. Here is a simplified example. The numbers are made up for illustration.

ItemAs reportedWith owner labor added
Sales$1,000,000$1,000,000
Food and beverage cost$300,000$300,000
Labor (wages, payroll taxes, benefits)$340,000$400,000
Prime cost$640,000$700,000
Prime cost as % of sales64%70%

Reported prime cost of 64 percent looks fine. Once $60,000 of unpaid owner labor is added, it is 70 percent, and that $60,000 comes straight out of earnings. This is the same issue we cover in owner compensation in a QoE report.

3. The owner, the chef, and key people

In many restaurants, the owner is the manager, and sometimes the chef or the face of the brand. If the food, the regulars, or the staff loyalty depend on that person, you are buying a business that may change the day they leave. Ask who runs the kitchen, who holds the supplier relationships, and how long the key staff have been there. Our guide to key man risk goes deeper.

4. The lease is part of the price

You can find a restaurant with excellent earnings and still lose the deal over its lease. Read it before you agree on a price.

5. Licenses, permits, and compliance

Health permits and any liquor license may not move to a new owner automatically. Rules vary by state and city, and in many places a buyer has to apply for their own license or approval, which takes time. Ask the licensing agency and your attorney early, and consider making the closing conditional on the licenses you need. Also ask about recent health inspection results, open violations, and any wage or labor claims.

6. Equipment, inventory, and what else you inherit

Kitchen equipment is expensive and wears out. Ask for an equipment list with age and condition, find out what is leased or has a lien on it, and budget for replacements you can see coming. Food and beverage inventory is perishable, so it is usually counted at closing. Our guide to inventory and receivables in due diligence covers this. Also ask about outstanding gift cards and event deposits, since customers can still redeem them after you take over.

7. Delivery apps and changing sales mix

Third party delivery platforms can add sales, but they also take a share of each order and sometimes affect pricing and margin. Look at gross sales against the payout actually received, and check whether delivery growth is adding profit or only adding volume. Also look at the trend in dine in sales, since a rise in delivery can mask a decline in the dining room.

What a QoE checks in a restaurant deal

A QoE will not judge the food, the location, or the brand. What it does is tell you whether the earnings are real and repeatable, so the price you negotiate is built on numbers you can trust.

Common questions

Are restaurant sales easy to verify?

Partly. POS data is detailed, which helps. Cash, tips, and delivery platforms make it harder. The most reliable approach is to tie POS totals to bank deposits and then to the tax returns.

Should I worry about cash sales?

Cash is normal in restaurants. Cash that was never recorded or never deposited is the problem. Treat any income the seller cannot document as unverified.

Does the liquor license transfer with the restaurant?

It depends on the state and city. In many places the buyer has to apply for their own license or approval, which takes time. Ask the licensing agency and your attorney early, and build the timing into the deal.

Is the lease more important than the earnings?

They are equally important. Strong earnings can disappear if the landlord will not assign the lease or the rent jumps at renewal. Review the lease before you commit to a price.

Bottom line: A restaurant is only worth what its verified earnings, its lease, and its licenses are worth together. Tie the sales to the bank, count all the labor, read the lease, and confirm the licenses before you pay a multiple.

Looking at a restaurant or another cash heavy business?

ClearView QoE tests whether the sales, margins, and add-backs hold up, so you can price the deal on verified earnings. CPA-reviewed, fixed fee, 10 business days or less.

Talk to Nick